Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: Approximate quotations
Browsing all 17 articles
Browse latest View live

By: Sid Smith

"A linguistically competent human should be able to accept the challenge of listening minutely and getting it down" Not sure what you mean, unless it's that reporters should have lightning shorthand....

View Article



By: Mark F.

Does the ability to record interviews make transcribing them fast enough to justify doing it as a routine practice? Finding a quote in a sound file isn't easy at all. Time spent doing that is time that...

View Article

By: Sid Smith

@ Mark F. "Does the ability to record interviews make transcribing them fast enough to justify doing it as a routine practice?" Yes, yes and yes. What could be a bigger priority than getting the quotes...

View Article

By: Clayton Burns

http://www.blinkx.com/videos/mark+liberman This tool could be of some use for political speech. Searching audio files should not in theory be difficult. I am willing to concede that recording and...

View Article

By: Sid Smith

"Once you have a recording, many programs and apps allow you to increase playback speed by up to a factor of 2 or 3, which also makes locating relevant regions faster" I still have the cassette...

View Article


By: Clayton Burns

–I don't know of any decent integrated systems (at least none suitable for the uses we're talking about) for using speech recognition to segment and search for content. But such things will be...

View Article

By: tpr

Mark, the embedded audio widget for the "When that kid gets the- gets the honor roll" is linked to the wrong audio clip. [(myl) Thanks. Fixed now.]

View Article

By: Martyn Cornell

Clayton Burns: "I think that there is some exaggeration about how hard it is to listen and write down what people say." Having done this - taking down verbatim peoples' speeches at meetings, in...

View Article


By: Will Keats-Osborn

Interesting and relevant anecdote: A self-described "human tape recorder" with "a talent for mentally recording lengthy conversations," Truman Capote thoughtfully included in his book Portraits and...

View Article


By: Jonathan D

Sid Smith didn't appreciate Mark Liberman adding the interpolation about deadlines in the comments above, but at least it was clear that it was Liberman's summary. It would be much worse if that...

View Article

By: maidhc

Today's San Francisco Chronicle has the following direct quotation in a featured article: "There's a way in which some violinists can slide or use certain kinds of bravado to emulate what an opera...

View Article

By: John

Any chance reporters here (or elsewhere) are using prepared texts given to them by campaigns, as they do with the State of the Union, for example, and Romney read it wrong?

View Article

By: James Joyce on Writing: “write dangerously” | The Coming of the Toads

[…] Menand questions whether what we read in Power's book are the actual words of Joyce or the "gist" of a conversation that took place decades prior to the book's publication. Would Menand have the...

View Article


By: Rob

The problem I have as an editor is that often people don't say what they mean. They might use the wrong word, or mess up the grammar, or - increasingly these days - mangle an idiom. Where it's obvious...

View Article

By: Brad Daniels

It seems to me that technology has already come up with a solution that is perfect for journalists who like to use written notes: I have a pen (a Livescribe Echo) which works with a special notebook to...

View Article


By: Unquotations and How to Avoid Them | Book How-To

[…] explores the topic further in follow-up articles here and here. Commenters offer a few possible explanations for inaccuracies—transcribing recorded […]

View Article

By: The Language Log scolds journalists for "approximate quotation" (again) |...

[...] unquotations“, 8/3/2012“More unquotations from the New Yorker“, 8/4/2012“Approximate quotations“, 8/11/2012“Quote approval and accurate quotation“, [...]

View Article

Browsing all 17 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images